Right Hand, Left Hand
We need a well crafted cocktail to compliment these dynamic duos, says the right brain. Actually we need two cocktails, replies the left brain – one for me and one for you. How creative of you, compliments the right brain. It’s only logical, demurs the left. The left brain then reaches for the “Right Hand” cocktail, a combination of aged rum, Carpano Antica sweet vermouth, Campari, and 2 dashes of chocolate bitters. This tasty treat was created by Michael McIlroy from Milk and Honey and Little Branch in New York City. The left brain analyzes these ingredients and suggests that the combination of a base spirit (rum here), vermouth and Campari makes this a variation of the classic Negroni cocktail. The right simply enjoys this incredible variation, which balances the rich flavors so well, and calls it, “just right.”
The Right Hand by Michael McIlroy
On the other hand, Sam Ross, also from Milk and Honey and Little Branch in NYC, suggests using a fine bourbon as the base spirit here instead of rum (or gin, as in a classic Negroni). His variation, featured in Jim Meehan’s fantastic PDT Cocktail Book, is known as the “Left Hand” cocktail. He describes it as a marriage of a Manhattan (rye and sweet vermouth) and a Negroni. Of course, a bourbon based negroni is also known as a “Boulevardier”, a drink we have discussed in detail previously for the “Red, White and Bourbon” cocktail. The right brain thinks that it is potentially acceptable artistic license to rename the drink after the simple addition of some chocolate bitters, as it reaches for the “Left Hand” cocktail in order to find out.
The Left Hand by Sam Ross
While comparing these two different but so similar cocktails, the brains have a hard time deciding which they like better. The fine aged rum tastes almost like aged whiskey, but smoother (and you know how I love aged rum), while the bourbon adds a spicy kick which is so nice. Whether you prefer yours with gin, aged rum, bourbon, or an altogether different base, this cocktail platform always seems to work out. Now, as you contemplate these excellent offerings, you are left (right?) with the age old drinking problem of two hands, one mouth. If you’ve solved the ambidextrous hexduos, however, you can probably work this one out as well. Cheers.
Right Hands and Left Hands required ... Cheers!
Right Hand by Michael McIlroy:
1 ¾ oz aged rum
¾ oz Carpano Antica (sweet vermouth)
¾ Campari
2 dashes Bittermens Xocolatl Mole Bitters
Stir with ice to chill / strain into a cocktail glass
Left Hand by Sam Ross:
1 ¾ oz bourbon
¾ oz Carpano Antica (sweet vermouth)
¾ Campari
2 dashes Bittermens Xocolatl Mole Bitters
Stir with ice to chill / strain